Gapping from a historical point of view

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.18148/zs/2026-2011

Keywords:

ellipsis, gapping, right node raising, afinite construction, mismatches, Early New High German

Abstract

Gapping is the optional omission of at least the finite verb in coordination. While in Modern Standard German (MSG) only mismatches in person-/number-marking between the gap and its antecedent occur, Early New High German (ENHG) also permits mismatches in 1) the verbal item itself (sein ‘be’ vs. haben ‘have’), 2) verbal function (lexical verb vs. grammatical verb), and 3) voice (active vs. passive). Moreover, non-coordinated clauses lacking a finite verb are typical for ENHG. They are known as afinite constructions. Previous studies have linked mismatched coordination ellipses to afinite constructions. Based on data drawn from the ENHG treebank, this study focuses on those mismatches, in which ENHG differs from MSG. I argue that ellipses in main-clause coordination should be analysed as a genuine coordination ellipsis, particularly gapping, and not as an ellipsis phenomenon resembling afinite constructions, even if they mismatch. I further claim that approaches to gapping that do not require full phonological identity between the gap and its antecedent can analyse these three patterns. Finally, there are indications that the standardisation process of High German may have contributed to the loss of mismatched gapping types 1)–3) and thus to restrictions on gapping in MSG.

Downloads

Published

2026-11-17

How to Cite

Lohmann, Marianna. “Gapping from a Historical Point of View”. Journal of the Linguistic Society of Germany, vol. 45, no. 3, Nov. 2026, https://doi.org/10.18148/zs/2026-2011.