Quantificational Readings of Indefinites with Focused Creation Verbs

Abstract

This paper looks at sentences with “quantificational indefinites,” discussed by Diesing (1992) and others. I propose that these sentences generate sets of alternatives of the form {p, not p and it’s possible that p}, which restrict the quantification by an extension of familiar focus principles. For example, in the sentence I usually read a book about slugs (on the relevant reading), usually quantifies over pairs <x,t> such that x is a book about slugs, t is a time interval, and one alternative is true from the set {I read x at t, I can but do not read x at t}. In addition to accounting for a well- known contrast between creation and non-creation verbs, this also explains a second contrast that Diesing’s analysis cannot account for.