The identity condition of right node raising in German

Experimental evidence

Autor/innen

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.18148/zs/2026-2013

Schlagwörter:

ellipsis, German, right node raising

Abstract

This article examines the identity condition of right node raising (RNR) in German, focusing on how morpho-phonological mismatches in the verbal domain between the target and its correlate affect the acceptability and processing of RNR. We relate experimental evidence from a cloze study, three rating studies, and a reading time study to the predictions of the central theoretical approaches to RNR mismatches that postulate (gradual) phonological, lexeme, or stem identity. Comparing RNR to gapping and full forms as baselines shows that while complete identity between target and correlate yields the highest ellipsis rates, mismatches do not result in acceptability or processing penalties. However, speakers are less likely to use RNR in the cloze task as the mismatch becomes increasingly morphologically marked, whereas for gapping we do not observe such a staircase-like pattern. While the rating and processing data of RNR align best with lexeme or stem identity, the cloze data are more in line with modified gradual phonological identity. Our findings suggest that RNR in German is more flexible than previously assumed, with acceptability and processing being tolerant of mismatches, but the cloze data showing greater sensitivity.

Veröffentlicht

2026-11-17

Erklärung zur Datenverfügbarkeit

The materials, data and scripts from this article can be found online at the following OSF storage: https://osf.io/f7g5k/files/osfstorage.

Zitationsvorschlag

Schäfer, Lisa, und Ingo Reich. „The identity condition of right node raising in German: Experimental evidence“. Zeitschrift für Sprachwissenschaft, Bd. 45, Nr. 3, November 2026, https://doi.org/10.18148/zs/2026-2013.